Is Matthew Stafford a HOFer?

By Andrew Bezio
In one of the most dismal franchises in NFL history (sorry Detroit), lies one of the most clever and skillful quarterbacks in recent history: former first overall pick Matthew Stafford. Should one of the most wasted careers in NFL history also be considered a Hall of Famer? Let’s dive in a little, shall we?
What makes a HOF QB?:
•How was the player during their prime?
•How much did they help their team? How crucial of a player was he?
•Most importantly, Championships
Let’s start with the fact that he wasn’t exactly given the greatest of influencers. Four different office of coordinator’s and three different head coaches in his career, they all share the same theme, none have been very good at their jobs. Jim Schwartz, Jim Caldwell (should have never been fired when he was), and Matt Patricia have a combined record of 77-105-1. Gross.
Stafford’s personal record of 73-85-1 isn’t much better, but the cook is only as good as the groceries provided to him. Right Parcells? He’s had one 1,000-yard running back: 2013 Reggie Bush with 1,006 to be exact. That also happens to be the last time the franchise has had a RB eclipse that number. Gross. “BuT hE hAd CaLvIn JoHnSoN!” Yeah…. that’s literally all he’s had to work with in his career.
Stafford will turn 33 in February,  so he’s in last half of his prime, maybe 5-6 good years left. He currently sits in the top 20 of all major quarterback categories, and if he remains relatively healthy, he might just crack the top 10 in each of them before he calls it quits.
“But isn’t he injury prone?”
Is he though? From 2011-2018 Stafford didn’t miss a single game. 128 straight in that timeframe. I wouldn’t necessarily call that injury prone.
Without Matthew Stafford at the helm, the Lions would be more of a laughingstock than they already are. Some may call him “Stat Padford,” but when you’re given one team defense that ranks in the top 10, coupled with mediocre (at best) across the board, sprinkle in a next-to-nothing running game, you have to 1.) Throw a ton (727 attempts in 2012) and 2.) Come back in games a ton.
He has had 30 career 4th-Quarter comeback wins (Manning had 43 and Brady has 38 and counting). Stafford had a NFL record 8 in 2016 alone. Pretty good company to be associated with.
Championships are the last talking point. Annnnndddddd…… Stafford has zero. A big ole goose egg. Zilch. Nada. Zip. None. Actually, Stafford is 0-3 in the postseason. His postseason stats, 63.2% comp, 908 yards, 4-3 TD-INT, 87.8 rating aren’t that bad, but when the lights shine brightest, Stafford dims like an overused light bulb. Tarkenton, Marino, Fouts, Moon, and Kelly are all QBs in the HOF without a SB win. Not saying Stafford is any of those individuals, but I’m saying there’s an argument to be made.
My personal opinion on this matter is, yes I believe Matthew Stafford is a holiday for quarterback, and he has time to build an already stellar résumé.
One other piece of advice for Mr. Stafford, next time the Lions offer you an extension, kindly decline. But if he does decide to be a Detroit Lifer, will he be the first Detroit quarterback elected to the Hall of Fame since Bobby Lane was elected in 1967? Only time will truly tell.
*Stafford’s Career Stats*
159 games
62.5% comp.
43,606 yds (Career Rank- 17th) (Fastest to 40K, 147 games)
273 TD (Career Rank- 17th)
141 INT (Career Rank- 68th)
89.6 Rating (Career Rank- 21st)

Leave a Reply


Recent posts


2020 2020-21 Season Aaron Rodgers Adam Eaton AJ Preller AJ Styles Alabama Aleksander Barkov Alexis Lefreniere Alex Ovechkin Alex Pietrangelo Alex Smith Alex Verdugo Allen Robinson Andre Drummond Andrei Vasilevskiy Andrew Benentendi Andy Dalton Anthony DeAngelo Anthony Rizzo Anze Kopitar Artemi Panarin Art Ross Trophy Asuka Atlanta Braves Atlanta Hawks Austin Auston Matthews Awards Baltimore Baseball Basketball Betting Big E Bill Belichick Blake Griffin Blake Snell Blowout Boston Boston Bruins Boston Celtics Boston Red Sox Bowen Byram Bradley Beal Brad Marchand Brad Stevens Brandon Moreno Bray Wyatt Brian Hoyer Brighton Brooklyn Nets Bubble Buddy Hield Buffalo Bills Calder Trophy Cale Makar Cam Newton Carey Price Caris LeVert Carolina Hurricanes Carson Wentz Carter Hart Charlie McAvoy Charlotte Hornets Chelsea Chicago Cubs Chicago White Sox Chris Godwin Chris Paul Christian Wood Christmas Cincinnati Clemson Cleveland Cavaliers Cleveland Indians College Football Playoff College Sports Colorado Avalanche Columbus Blue Jackets Combat Sports Conference Championships Connor Hellebuyck Connor McDavid Contenders COVID-19 Cowboys Crystal Palace Dallas Mavericks Danny Ainge David Pastrnak Dax Prescott DeAndre Jordan Deiveson Figueiredo Derrick Henry Derrick Rose DeShaun Watson Detroit Pistons Detroit Tigers Dominick Reyes Donovan Mitchell Don Sweeney Dougie Hamilton Draft Drew McIntyre Dwayne Johnson Dylan Cozens Eddie Rosario England Eric Bledsoe Expansion Fernando Tatis Jr. Fines Florida Football Francisco Lindor Frank Lampard Frank Selke Free Agency Free Agents Fulham Futbol General Manager George Springer Gerrit Cole Giannis Antokounmpo Goals Goldberg Golden State Warriors Gregg Popovich Hall of Fame Hart Memorial Hockey Houston Rockets Houston Texans Hunter Renfroe Hurt Business Ice Shaker Igor Shesterkin Ilya Sorokin Indiana Pacers Isaiah Thomas J.T. Realmuto Jackie Bradley Jr. Jacob DeGrom Jacoby Brissett Jakub Zboril Jameis Winston James Harden James Norris Jarrett Allen Jarrett Stidham Jason Robertson Javier Baez Jaylen Brown Jaylon Brown Jayson Tatum Jed Hoyer Jimmy Garoppolo Joanna Jedrzejczyk Joe Flacco Joel Embiid John Gibson Jonathan Huberdeau Jon Jones Jordan Clarkson Jose Aldo Josh Norris Jrue Holiday Julius Randle Jurickson Profar Justin Gaehtje Kansas City Kansas City Chiefs Kawhi Leonard Kemba Walker Kenny Golladay Kevin Durant Kevin Owens Kirill Kaprizov Kris Bryant Kyrie Irving LaMarcus Aldridge LaMelo Ball Lana Lance Lynn Larry Nance Jr. Las Vegas Lavar Ball Lawsuit Leadership Legal Leon Draisaitl Lions Liverpool Lonzo Ball Los Angeles Angels Los Angeles Clippers Los Angeles Lakers LSU Luka Doncic Mackenzie Blackwood Malcolm Brogdon Marcell Ozuna Marcus Mariota Mark Stone Matt Murray Matt Ryan Matt Stafford Memories Miami Dolphins Michael Jordan Mika Zibanejad Minnesota Timberwolves Minnesota Wild Miro Heiskanen Mitch Trubisky MLB Moments Montreal Canadiens MVP Myles Turner Nashville Predators Nathan McKinnon Naughty NBA NBA Draft NCAA New Day New England Patriots New Orleans Pelicans New York Jets New York Mets New York Rangers New York Yankees NFC East NFL NHL Nia Jax Nice Nikola Jokic Nikola Vucevic Notre Dame Ohio St. Ohio State Oklahoma Oklahoma City Thunder Orlando Magic Outfield Patrice Bergeron Patrick Mahomes Paul George Payton Pritchard Petr Yan PGA Philadelphia Flyers Philadelphia Phillies Phillip Danault Phoenix Suns Pittsburgh Penguins Playoffs Predictions Premier League Presidents Trophy Rafael Stone Randy Orton Ravens Relegations Robin Lehner Rocket Richard Roman Josi Roman Reigns Rookies Russell Wilson Ryan Fitzpatrick Ryan Kesler Ryan O'Reilly Sacramento Kings Safety Sam Darnold Sammy Watkins San Antonio Spurs San Diego Padres Sean Couturier Sebastian Aho Semi Ojeleye Shayna Baszler Sheffield United Sidney Crosby Slam Diego Soccer Sports Stanley Cup Stan Van Gundy Steal Steelers Stephen Curry Steven Adams Steven Stamkos Super Bowl LV Suspensions Tampa Bay Buccaneers Tampa Bay Lightning Tampa Bay Rays Taurean Prince Texans Texas A&M Texas Rangers Thanksgiving The Rock Tim Stutzle TLC Tom Brady Tom Wilson Tony Ferguson Toronto Blue Jays Toronto Maple Leafs Toronto Raptors Tottenham trade Trade Deadline Trades Trevor Bauer Trevor Lawrence Trevor Zegras Tuukka Rask Tyler Glasnow Ty Lue Tyrod Taylor Ty Smith UFC Underrated Vancouver Canucks Vegas Golden Knights Vezina Trophy Victor Hedman Victor Oladipo Washington Washington Capitals Washington Football Team Washington Nationals Washington Wizards West Brom Wild Card William Karlsson William M. Jennings Winnipeg Jets World Series WrestleMania WWE Yu Darvish Zach Werenski Zhang Weili