Jane Doe et al. v. Deshaun Watson?

By Joe Scibelli, Esq.

Before we start this article, first and foremost, nothing of what I am writing about should be misconstrued as legal advice. 

I’m writing about all the questions and disturbing allegations concerning NFL quarterback Deshaun Watson. I have written a lot about Watson lately and it troubles me that this is the newest development in this off-season. I want to shed some light (which is strictly opinion) on questions I’ve read throughout social media/comments on the events taking place. 

Deshaun’s case is disgusting to say the least. The facts surrounding the case and the allegations are vile and repugnant. However, people are questioning a big aspect of all these lawsuits, “why are all this money and demands for it involved.” In short, the law cannot make it so the bad thing that happened to you, never had happened. It happened, these massage therapists are alleging Watson wronged them, and how cases are handled, you get money as damages. That’s how it is and will be until we develop time travel. What I struggle with also is when people say, “why did these lawyers send letters demanding $100,000 to settle the case.” Fun fact, I send these letters all the time. Maybe not for cases like what’s going on in Houston, but for basic slip and falls, car accidents, breach of contracts, and other crazy matters. Demand letters are part of the process. Courts are over packed, and the system is clogged tenfold due to COVID-19. 95 percent of civil cases settle, but that number doesn’t include possible cases that settle prior to a lawsuit. Actually, the law encourages civil attorneys to settle matters both before a lawsuit and during.

What Tony Buzbee was trying to do is start the conversation. What better way than demand a ton of money or threaten suit. However, I know attorneys who would prefer to file suit. Yet, I can imagine these victims wouldn’t want their names and dramatic stories being put on public record making a private settlement reasonable. Now that the Judge is ordering that a Plaintiff to reveal her identity which more of the motions are soon to come. 

Buzbee is trying to make all his clients whole and doing it the best way is his client requesting with his opinion in mind. Buzbee stated, “we made a legit demand. You rejected it.” This happens all the time and the client decides if a lawsuit is filed or not, attorneys just advise. Nevertheless, I honestly believe that Ashley Solis, one of the named Plaintiffs to come forward, when she stated she is not “doing this just for money.” She sought legal help and, civilly, this is how you do it. For civil matters, the court/jury determines liability. For criminal cases, the question is if the defendant is guilty. 

Criminally speaking, unfortunately for Solis and all the other victims, is a lot higher burden. For civil cases, the burden of proof, depending on the claim, is that the Plaintiff must prove more likely than not the Defendant was wrong, which in legal terms is defined as Preponderance of the Evidence. Also to just file suit, you need to do so in good faith, which is broad and vague. To get an indictment or warrant, law enforcement or the local district attorney’s office needs to provide the court or a grand jury enough evidence to find Probable Cause. Preponderance of the Evidence is roughly 51% percent Defendant did it, compared to Probable Cause, which can range depending on the Judge or Grand Jury 65% – 85% the Defendant did it. Furthermore, for criminal cases, the State needs to prove Actus Reus, meaning the Defendant did the illegal act and depending on the statute, Mens Rea, which means the Defendant had the mental state of mind of doing the act required by law, and Causation, which is self-explanatory. 

This is a high burden, and Judges can give the State a hard time when they present the case. I can see the DA electing to use a Grand Jury to indict Watson if it gets that point because these are serious habitual allegations. Watson’s legal team, I bet, are trying to resolve this matter behind the scenes and if what Watson is being accused of is true, trying to punch holes in the case to prevent an arrest warrant. The Houston PD is building its case, and Watson’s legal team is in the process of weakening it, like when Deshaun-supporting massage therapists came out and said Watson is a good client. Not the best evidence, arguably terrible evidence because certain rules in the Federal Rules of Evidence, but it does punch holes in the case against Watson. Deshaun is fighting a two-sided battle, one-side all the civil claims which will be a financial hit, maybe a lot even for Watson. On the other side is the real concern for Watson. A criminal trial doesn’t settle (meaning both sides are unhappy), they plea or worse convicted. Another fun fact, the Judge decides the sentence even if you plea, but judges are more than likely to listen to the State’s recommendation. Watson’s legal team has a lot of work ahead of them, and discovery is going to be long with a lot of hearings concerning legal issues. In short, Watson is in a terrible spot. 

The repercussions are already taking place: loss of sponsors, deals, and the incurring legal fees. Watson’s alleged actions are despicable, but when the Plaintiff Attorney Buzbee demanded $100,000 prior to filing suit, he probably demanded higher than the case is worth, civilly speaking. This case is still fresh, and there is a lot of speculation and hearsay present, and will present itself in the future. I can only hope the truth comes out whatever it may be and that our legal system does its due diligence to resolve this matter in the manner it deems fit.

Leave a Reply

Categories

Recent posts

Tags

Tags
2020 2020-21 Season Aaron Rodgers Adam Eaton AJ Preller AJ Styles Alabama Aleksander Barkov Alexis Lefreniere Alex Ovechkin Alex Pietrangelo Alex Smith Alex Verdugo Allen Robinson Andre Drummond Andrei Vasilevskiy Andrew Benentendi Andy Dalton Anthony DeAngelo Anthony Rizzo Anze Kopitar Artemi Panarin Art Ross Trophy Asuka Atlanta Braves Atlanta Hawks Austin Auston Matthews Awards Baltimore Baseball Basketball Betting Big E Bill Belichick Blake Griffin Blake Snell Blowout Boston Boston Bruins Boston Celtics Boston Red Sox Bowen Byram Bradley Beal Brad Marchand Brad Stevens Brandon Moreno Bray Wyatt Brian Hoyer Brighton Brooklyn Nets Bubble Buddy Hield Buffalo Bills Calder Trophy Cale Makar Cam Newton Carey Price Caris LeVert Carolina Hurricanes Carson Wentz Carter Hart Charlie McAvoy Charlotte Hornets Chelsea Chicago Cubs Chicago White Sox Chris Godwin Christian Wood Christmas Cincinnati Clemson Cleveland Cavaliers Cleveland Indians College Football Playoff College Sports Colorado Avalanche Columbus Blue Jackets Combat Sports Conference Championships Connor Hellebuyck Connor McDavid Contenders COVID-19 Cowboys Crystal Palace Dallas Mavericks Danny Ainge David Pastrnak Dax Prescott DeAndre Jordan Deiveson Figueiredo Derrick Henry Derrick Rose DeShaun Watson Detroit Pistons Detroit Tigers Dominick Reyes Don Sweeney Dougie Hamilton Draft Drew McIntyre Dwayne Johnson Dylan Cozens Eddie Rosario England Eric Bledsoe Expansion Fernando Tatis Jr. Fines Florida Football Francisco Lindor Frank Lampard Frank Selke Free Agency Free Agents Fulham Futbol General Manager George Springer Gerrit Cole Giannis Antokounmpo Goals Goldberg Golden State Warriors Gregg Popovich Hall of Fame Hart Memorial Hockey Houston Rockets Houston Texans Hunter Renfroe Hurt Business Ice Shaker Igor Shesterkin Ilya Sorokin Indiana Pacers Isaiah Thomas J.T. Realmuto Jackie Bradley Jr. Jacob DeGrom Jacoby Brissett Jakub Zboril Jameis Winston James Harden James Norris Jarrett Allen Jarrett Stidham Jason Robertson Javier Baez Jaylen Brown Jaylon Brown Jayson Tatum Jed Hoyer Jimmy Garoppolo Joanna Jedrzejczyk Joe Flacco John Gibson Jonathan Huberdeau Jon Jones Jordan Clarkson Jose Aldo Josh Norris Jrue Holiday Jurickson Profar Justin Gaehtje Kansas City Kansas City Chiefs Kawhi Leonard Kemba Walker Kenny Golladay Kevin Durant Kevin Owens Kirill Kaprizov Kris Bryant Kyrie Irving LaMarcus Aldridge LaMelo Ball Lana Lance Lynn Larry Nance Jr. Las Vegas Lavar Ball Lawsuit Leadership Legal Leon Draisaitl Lions Liverpool Lonzo Ball Los Angeles Angels Los Angeles Clippers Los Angeles Lakers LSU Mackenzie Blackwood Malcolm Brogdon Marcell Ozuna Marcus Mariota Mark Stone Matt Murray Matt Ryan Matt Stafford Memories Miami Dolphins Michael Jordan Mika Zibanejad Minnesota Timberwolves Minnesota Wild Miro Heiskanen Mitch Trubisky MLB Moments Montreal Canadiens MVP Myles Turner Nashville Predators Nathan McKinnon Naughty NBA NBA Draft NCAA New Day New England Patriots New Orleans Pelicans New York Jets New York Mets New York Rangers New York Yankees NFC East NFL NHL Nia Jax Nice Nikola Vucevic Notre Dame Ohio St. Ohio State Oklahoma Oklahoma City Thunder Orlando Magic Outfield Patrice Bergeron Patrick Mahomes Paul George Payton Pritchard Petr Yan PGA Philadelphia Flyers Philadelphia Phillies Phillip Danault Phoenix Suns Pittsburgh Penguins Playoffs Predictions Premier League Presidents Trophy Rafael Stone Randy Orton Ravens Relegations Robin Lehner Rocket Richard Roman Josi Roman Reigns Rookies Russell Wilson Ryan Fitzpatrick Ryan Kesler Ryan O'Reilly Sacramento Kings Safety Sam Darnold Sammy Watkins San Antonio Spurs San Diego Padres Sean Couturier Sebastian Aho Semi Ojeleye Shayna Baszler Sheffield United Sidney Crosby Slam Diego Soccer Sports Stanley Cup Stan Van Gundy Steal Steelers Steven Adams Steven Stamkos Super Bowl LV Suspensions Tampa Bay Buccaneers Tampa Bay Lightning Tampa Bay Rays Taurean Prince Texans Texas A&M Texas Rangers Thanksgiving The Rock Tim Stutzle TLC Tom Brady Tom Wilson Tony Ferguson Toronto Blue Jays Toronto Maple Leafs Toronto Raptors Tottenham trade Trade Deadline Trades Trevor Bauer Trevor Lawrence Trevor Zegras Tuukka Rask Tyler Glasnow Ty Lue Tyrod Taylor Ty Smith UFC Underrated Vancouver Canucks Vegas Golden Knights Vezina Trophy Victor Hedman Victor Oladipo Washington Washington Capitals Washington Football Team Washington Nationals Washington Wizards West Brom Wild Card William Karlsson William M. Jennings Winnipeg Jets World Series WrestleMania WWE Yu Darvish Zach Werenski Zhang Weili